May 17, 2009

Movie Review – X-Men Origins: Wolverine

Filed under: Movie Review,X-Men Franchise — Rodney Twelftree @ 12:01 am
google plus Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverinetumblr Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverinelinkedin Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverinepinterest Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverineshare save 120 16 Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

X Men Origins Wolverine Review Logo v5.1 Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

- Summary -

Director : Gavin Hood
Cast :
Hugh Jackman, Liev Schreiber, Danny Huston, Lynn  Collins, Taylor Kitsch, Will.I.Am, Kevin Durand, Dominic Monaghan, Ryan Reynolds.
Year of Release :
2009
Length : 2 hours.
Synopsis:
Two brothers, born well before the American civil war, and who seemingly live forever and cannot be killed, are recruited to a special government task force to locate meteorite fragments that have fallen to earth. But when one of the brothers refuses to resort to violence during the mission, this sets in motion a chain of events that will see mutant pitted against mutant, and eventually, brother against brother.

Review : Energetic, yet fatally flawed comic-b0ok film which falls far from the lofty heights of The Dark Knight, Iron Man or even, gulp, the original X-Men for character development and narrative cohesion. A plethora of second tier characters, all with limited screen time, simple seem to get in the way of the mighty Wolverine, without really adding anything to the mythos of the character. Second rate effects, and a script bordering on anemic, only add to this film’s woes. Enjoyable only as a lowbrow entry into the mighty X-Men saga that does nothing to further Fox’s cause to make more.

 

***********************

Entertaining, yet narratively diabolical, follow-up to the original X-Men trilogy, X-Men Origins: Wolverine suffers too much from a case of bending the story to suit the historical facts of the previous films. By being required to conform to the story set out in the Singer/Ratner films, director Gavin Hood finds himself curtailed in his ability to explore the character too much; essentially, whatever the film is about, we all know that eventually Logan (for that, if you’ve been watching, is Wolverine’s name!) has to gain amnesia, find himself interacting with other mutants, and obtain a skeletal structure made from adamantium, the hardest known substance on the planet. And, truthfully, Hood ticks all the boxes. The mandatory triple-claw sequences scattered throughout the film, as well as superfluous and unnecessary fight sequences between characters with little (or no) development, ensure that Wolverine goes down as merely overdressed nonsense, like Daredevil and Elektra before him.

The character of Wolverine is one that’s endured for decades, from his earliest manifestations in the Marvel Comics universe, to the more recent cinematic triumphs of the aforementioned Singer/Ratner combos, all of which ranged from excellent to above average. Here, Gavin Hood is given the unenviable task of trying to bring together a script written by somebody with the mental age of a six year old and try turning it into a film with depth. It’s an impossible, herculean task, and one that Hood simply isn’t up to. The enormous weight of expectation preceding this film is completely shattered by what can only be described as a complete waste of your time.

633695421909596569 Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

Wolverine flies towards a helicopter.

Wolverine (Jackman) and his brother Victor (Schreiber) are both mutants, each with the ability to survive death due to their body’s natural resistance to harm. They don’t ever seem to age, living through the late 19th and early 20th century becoming engaged in various conflicts (the US Civil War, both World Wars, before being executed for disorderly conduct during the Vietnam war) before they are recruited by a government agent William Stryker (Danny Huston) to hunt down a mysterious meteorite which has landed somewhere in the Vietnamese jungle. When the group they are with, including a number of other mutants, become extremely violent to get what they want, Logan abandons the cause and flees, leaving Victor behind. Years later, Strker returns to inform Logan that somebody is hunting down and killing his former team-mates, and this leads to Logan’s girlfriend, Kayla, being murdered by Victor. Vengeance fills Logans heart, and he sides with Stryker to obtain an upgrade to his body, a transfusion of a strange metal to his own skeleton that will make him even more indestructible, and more powerful, than ever before. When Logan realises that he is double-crossed, however, and that Kayla is really in the employ of Stryker for his own ends, Logan goes on a rampage, in order to find the truth.

There are a number of key issues in Wolverine that cause it to be a less entertaining film than it otherwise could have been. First, the fact that the story had to, just had to, conform to the history and timeline of the previous X-Men films, and their characters, means that there’s almost no flexibility in telling this story from a continuity perspective. Hood is left with almost no possible outcome for the film’s conclusion, a wobbly, misconstructed “how do we get Wolverine into the situation he finds himself in at the beginning of the original X-Men” sequence that serves merely to close the circle on the film series. The let-down of this resolution, and the somewhat cavalier way that it’s shoehorned into the films concluding act, makes any tension the film may have had evaporate like a puddle on a hot day. Second, the lack of decent scripting in this film, a more comic-booky feel to the movie, hamstrings what could have been a great dramatic arc degenerate into a merely average one at best. The tension between Logan and Victor, as brothers, and their gradual emotional splitting, could have been the real crux upon which this film would have been built, yet this natural storyline is never fully explored. Jackman and Schreiber seem merely brothers in character only, almost as if they are going through the motions of being so, which is hard due to the calibre of both performers to really nail a scene. Schreibers character, Victor, was portrayed by a completely different actor in X-Men, Tyler Mane (the big shaggy one), and there wasn’t (to my knowledge) a tip of the hat to this, or any real sense of connection between the two films.

xmen origins wolverine tub Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

I am SO going to kick your ass!!!

But the biggest caveat to the film would have to be the 2 dimensional characters that flood the film. Truthfully, I probably don’t know enough of the X-Men world to appreciate and understand all the little Easter eggs in the film, and I certainly don’t claim to be the franchise’s biggest fan. But as a decidedly non-fanatic, I expected to be at least entertained. I was, but only by the barest of margins, and as a film, this certainly isn’t a great one. The plethora of extra characters, including Gambit and John Wraith (an impressive film debut by will.i.am) all appear to be quite higgledy-piggledy, added with no sense of forethought or narrative logic: they exist merely to exist, and this reduces their screen power, if you will. A charming scene with Logan escaping the military fortress where he gathers his new adamantium skeleton, and ending up naked and freezing in a farmers barn, is handled with the most astute delicacy by Hood, until the obligatory explosion and shock deaths made for a most engaging Wolverine-versus-helicopter sequence. This is as close to a true family scenario as Logan has had in years, and it all comes crashing down quite brutally, obliged by Victor and the military. An enormous fat dude, who takes most of Logan’s best punches, seems the most unintentionally hilarious character, although the way Hood directs these scenes it appears that wasn’t meant to be the case.

On the plus side, there’s a lot to be said to Jackman’s portrayal of Wolverine. He’s a magnetic screen presence, the camera loves him and he has nailed this character so well it’s hard to see anybody else doing better. Jackman is deservedly applauded for bringing true emotion and grit to what is, essentially, a formidably violent character, and makes us love watching him tear bad guys to shreds. There’s a moment, when Stryker temps him with added power, where Wolverine swears he’ll do what’s required, no law, no rules, that you just know somewhere, somehow, the enemies of Wolverine just shat their pants. Jackman is such a good actor that he almost rises above the mediocrity that surrounds him in this film: almost. Yet for all his immense screen talent, Jackman is in constant flux with the one thing he can’t control: the actual script. Forced to deliver lines Bryan Singer wouldn’t crap on, Jackman is reduced from a great actor portraying a wonderful character, to a great actor being embarrassed by the cheesy, one-note humor of talentless scripting hacks more in tune with pre-teen children than modern cinema audiences. The fact that David Benioff and Skip Woods got paid to deliver a script like this is sheer stupidity. This script is a diabolical mess, and it reduces both Jackman, and the film as a whole, to a sodden waste of time.

3340542267 c7905857a0 Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

Logan & Victor (Liev Schreiber) face the firing squad.

Look, as a film event, Wolverine is sure to remain a slight speed bump in Jackman’s career. He’s made worse than this *cough* Kate & Leopold *cough* and it hasn’t done him any harm. I just wish that he’d do a film that would do his acting ability some justice, a really meaty dramatic part that stretches him as an actor, rather than simply resort to action/adventure charm-school fare that makes him such a hit with the ladies. I know he was good in Australia, and The Prestige showed glimpses of his talent, however I think he’s got so much more to show us than simply doing another Wolverine film. Give the claws a break Hugh, and take on a more challenging, intellectually stimulating role.

Wolverine is a limp, half-assed entry into the X-Men canon, and one cannot help but think that this might just be the nail in the coffin for the extraneous ensemble films for the series for the moment. It’s entertaining on a level only attained by the aforementioned Daredevil, which is to say, it had so much potential that was just never fully realized. Daredevil could have been an awesome film, yet, it wasn’t. Wolverine, for all it has going for it, is strangely inept and completely devoid of real, dynamic emotion. Not as bad as Ghost Rider, and not as good as The Incredible Hulk, Wolverine is merely adequate, although barely that in itself.

4 Star Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

 Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine
1.thumbnail Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine

Rodney is the Editor-In-Chief of Fernby Films, and has been appreciating films seriously since 1993. Rodney’s first foray into online reviews was for a now-defunct online Australian DVD store, before starting up fernbyfilms.com when that enterprise fell through, in 2007. Rodney lives in the South Australian city of Adelaide, with his wife and two young children, whom he loves very much.

facebook Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine twitter Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine youtube Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine skype Movie Review   X Men Origins: Wolverine 



4 Comments »

  1. Seriously Rodney, it was not BAD, simply not good.

    I actually quite liked it and so did my friend.

    Sure it's not as good as Star Trek, but it was entertaining. I only wish there was more Gambit in it, I really loved him as a character and they kinda devalued his presence more than I'd have liked, although he still kicked some ass.

    If I didn't know you better I'd say your problem is that you actually had high expectations of an Xmen film, but that's laughable.

    Overall I'd rate it 7 out of 10. A bit better script might be able to elevate it up a notch or two, but it was still entertaining fun that was worth going to the movies for.

      Michael Kubler — May 17, 2009 @ 11:57 am

  2. I agree, I wish there was more Gambit in it too, as this character was criminally underused. But the film seemed to cluttered, too overwhelmingly filled with character with little/no backstory, and that diluted the overall effect. Sure, the X-Men films all had a plethora of characters, but at least they were introduced and explained to make us care about them in a small way, unlike this film. I didn't have high expectations for this film, which is a shame, because after the exceedingly good X-Men films, I wanted, so badly, for this film to succeed. Unfortunately, it will not, and will probably put an end to any further explorations of the X-Men team in the near future. It had moments of quality, but those moments were outdone by the lacklustre storyline and diabolical scripting.

      Rodney Twelftree — May 17, 2009 @ 10:44 pm

  3. Fellas, please! This film grossed $80 million in its opening week JUST in the U.S. alone. Star Trek only managed to get to $72 million, so it already has succeeded. Admittedly, Star Trek is the superior film (yes, I've seen it THREE times already… and I will write a review for it, Your Rodness – it's so hard to put the words down about something so awesome), but I did enjoy Wolverine. 8 out of 10 for me. Everyone who I went and saw it with stated that they enjoyed it. Look on the bright side… at least it's not Fast And Furious. How that managed to blitz The Dark Knight for its opening weekend staggers me.

      ColinGregBowden — May 21, 2009 @ 2:03 am

  4. 8/10 for this mess, Colin? Oh man….. I would be keen to hear what you think of the latest flick, The Wolverine, and whether that is better or worse than this one!!!

    I too am staggered at F&F managing to eclipse TDK, but we all know which of those films stands the test of time some years later…. ;)

      Rodney — July 31, 2013 @ 10:37 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.

© 2007-2014 Fernby Films All Rights Reserved

Registered with Copyright Safeguard
%d bloggers like this: